• Home
  • About Celtics Town
  • Contact Us
  • NBA Blog Links
  • Privacy Policy

For Billy Hunter, NBA players association, disclaimer of interest could be another option

Decertification isn’t the only option to dissolve the NBA players association and apply pressure to the owners, according to Ken Berger. There’s also a slim possibility Billy Hunter could step aside as executive director of the union, in a legal maneuver called a disclaimer of interest.

The legal term for this would be a disclaimer of interest, which would only require a letter from Hunter to Stern advising him that the National Basketball Players Association no longer exists as the bargaining unit for the players.

The advantage of this for the players would be that, once the letter is sent, their attorneys would not have to wait 45-60 days for the National Labor Relations Board to authorize an election to formally dissolve the union. With a disclaimer of interest, the players could almost immediately commence an anti-trust lawsuit against the NBA, said Gabe Feldman, director of the Sports Law Center at Tulane University.

“The owners have threatened to, in some ways, end the negotiations if (the players) don’t agree by Wednesday, because 47 percent is a non-starter — we all know that,” Feldman said. “So the owners have given the players an ultimatum with an artificial deadline, and it may force the players to respond with their own ultimatum. But both are destructive of the negotiation process.

“Clearly, what David Stern has said is designed to push the players to make a concession with the threat of essentially ending the negotiations,” Feldman said. “And that’s what the players would be doing by threatening to dissolve the union.” …

The question of how Stern and the owners would respond to the players’ own ultimatum is a risky and unknown game of roulette that union leaders will have to decide if they want to play.

“It could go either way,” Feldman said. “It could cause enough owners to be skittish and want to avoid the risk of anti-trust litigation — because if they lose there, it’s a huge loss. … The other side is that it could cause Stern and the owners to say, ‘We’re not going to let you manipulate labor law by threatening us with an anti-trust suit and we’re going to take a stand.

“The question becomes: Do all of these threats bring the sides closer together,” Feldman said, “or push them further apart?”

In the case of decertification, the NBPA would remain functional during the 45 or so days between a petition for decertification and an actual election. A disclaimer of interest would dissolve the union immediately, although — due to the possibility it is being used strictly as a bargaining tactic — it would have a lesser chance of holding up in court.

Another thought I had, which wasn’t addressed in Berger’s report: If Billy Hunter steps aside, he would probably be forfeiting his job and remaining salary. While he might consider doing that for the sake of the union, this option seems like a slim one that would only be used as a desperate recourse to Stern’s ultimatum. Then again, times might call for a desperate recourse.

Ugh.

Related posts:

  1. NBA Lockout news: JaVale McGee does JaVale McGee-ish things, Billy Hunter brings up contraction
  2. Billy Hunter: “I’m convinced that this was just all part of the plan.” Awesome, huh?
  3. NBA owners file two lawsuits against the players
  4. David Stern needs to back down? Uh-oh
  5. NBA writers blast owners; Paul Allen wants players to get 40% (!) of BRI?

categories Around the NBA | Jay King | November 8, 2011

categories Billy Hunter, NBA lockout

4 Responses to “For Billy Hunter, NBA players association, disclaimer of interest could be another option”

  1. paul says:
    November 8, 2011 at 9:01 am

    I think there are some false memes here. One is this notion, which no one ever seems to challenge, that the key and only reasonable goal is to ‘bring the parties closer together’. My God, people, if the deal is a bad one, as most of us seem to agree, why is bringing the parties closer to agreement on it necessarily the only or the desirable outcome? Why SHOULDN’T we want to see negotiaions reset? I think that’s exactly what we should want to see. I miss basketball, but not enough to want to see the playes take a raw deal.

    Also, I think it’s wrong to assume that abandoning the union is a desperate move by the players. If the union is incompetent or corrupt, as it appears to be, abandoning it may be the only reasonable thing to do.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    • Jay King says:
      November 8, 2011 at 9:49 am

      If negotiations are reset, what makes you believe the owners will change down the line though? And I agree, going to the courts might be the reasonable thing to do. But taking a shit deal might actually be reasonable, too.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

      • paul says:
        November 8, 2011 at 9:13 pm

        So what you are saying is exactly what Kessler said this negotiation is saying about the players: that they are nothing but plantation workers. Think about it. You are saying that the players have no power in this situation. What does that really mean, to say that workers have no power and that owners get to dictate to them?

        I think the players do have power, but that won’t mean anything as long as the owners think they won’t use it.

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

        • paul says:
          November 8, 2011 at 9:23 pm

          thanks for reminding me how much i dislike you Jeff. Yes, I’m sure that from your point of view it’s reasonable for the players to give in to a bunch of suited and tied thugs. Well said. Nice propaganda

          Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

← David Stern throwing NBA players a bone? NBA could soften stance on lockout system issues at last second
Avery Bradley in Israel: An update on the young Celtic →
  • Tiq IQ

    Boston Celtics tickets
  • Recent Posts

    • Terrence Williams arrested for brandishing a firearm
    • Washburn: Paul Pierce’s family is preparing for relocation
    • Exit Interviews: Courtney Lee
    • Exit Interviews: Terrence Williams
    • Exit Interviews: Jeff Green
  • Recent Comments

    • James on Terrence Williams arrested for brandishing a firearm
    • sam on Washburn: Paul Pierce’s family is preparing for relocation
    • NBA Celtics Fan » Boston Celtics Daily Links – news, rumors, and opinion on Washburn: Paul Pierce’s family is preparing for relocation
    • RSN » Boston Celtics Daily Links 5/18 on Washburn: Paul Pierce’s family is preparing for relocation
    • NBA Celtics Fan » Boston Celtics Daily Links 5/18 on Washburn: Paul Pierce’s family is preparing for relocation
  • Follow us


  • Blogroll

    • Ball Don't Lie
    • Boston Celtics Tickets
    • Boston Globe Celtics Coverage
    • Boston Herald Celtics Coverage
    • Celtics Blog
    • Celtics Life
    • CLNS Radio
    • CSNNE Celtics Coverage
    • D-League Digest
    • ESPNBoston Celtics Blog
    • Posting and Toasting
    • Red's Army
    • State of the Celtics
    • TrueHoop
    • Twitter Sports – Celtics
    • WEEI's Green Street
  •   Celtics Rumors & News >

Celtics Town | Boston Celtics blog | Celtics news is powered by WordPress

Dansette