Roster Countdown: 15. Fab Melo
With the most exciting moments of the offseason behind us, Celtics Town is counting down the Celtics’ roster from 16 to one. We’ll offer speculation on the role each player has to play, and where they’ll be in the rotation as we look towards the upcoming season. If you missed the last column in this series you can check it out here.It’s inevitable that at some point every year I’ll have a tantrum about Doc Rivers not playing rookies, and consequently say something ridiculous like “We don’t have any bigs, playing JaJuan is our only chance!” or “Luke Harangody is just what this team needs!” I do not expect to be having any such moment regarding Fab Melo this year. I’ve seen him play and he’s not ready. And I know Ryan Hollins made the rotation last year, and I know this means I have Jason Collins ranked higher than Fab, and I know that dead last in the rotation is not where any of us like to imagine a first round pick. Fab is just not ready right now, but he will be one day.
Fab Melo is really good at one thing, blocking shots (2.9 per game last year at Syracuse). He doesn’t really rebound (5.8 RPG) and his offensive game, in addition to being virtually non-existent (7.8 PPG), can also be pretty frightening to watch at times. While Greg Stiemsma made his way into the rotation for his shot blocking talent, Melo’s is (as of now) irrelevant because he does not yet know how to defend on an NBA level. That sounded really bad, let me explain. Fab spent his college career playing in Boehiem’s 2-3 zone, and when he was forced out of that system in summer league his blocks dropped to just 1.1 per game. He’s only been playing basketball for a few years, so while other players have at least some experience playing man-to-man, Fab doesn’t really have that foundation to fall back on. There were a number of times this summer where Fab was just a tenth of a second late on a block attempt, because he’s not sure where he’s supposed to be. As he adjusts to playing in Doc’s system defense this will get remedied, but if you put him in an NBA game today the opposing team would pick-and-roll him to death.
It’s best to think of Melo as a project. During summer league he was at his best running the defense, and now he has a great mentor in Kevin Garnett who shares his vocal style (I mean talking on defense, not unloading expletives on people). It will take some time before Fab’s pick-and-roll and isolation defense is good enough for the NBA, and while I don’t think it’ll be this season, I can’t say for sure. Fab has been billed by both himself and his coach as a hard worker (backed up by his dramatic weight loss between his freshman and sophomore years of college) and extremely coachable. With a little conditioning and a lot of KG it’s completely possible that in time Fab can be the seven-foot-Ibaka-help-defender I believe (ok, convinced myself) he can be. For now, Melo is a bit of an enigma and that’s okay. It’ll take time, but KG has forged impressive defenders out of a lot less.
You can follow Jordan on Twitter, @OffensiveG.
Related posts:
- Roster Countdown: 16. Jamar Smith
- In which I try talking myself into Fab Melo
- Throwing some dimes: The Melo-Pierce comparison
- Jared Sullinger and Fab Melo, two entirely different species who could one day form a nice tandem
- Boston Celtics Las Vegas Summer League observations, Day 1: Fab Melo reveals promise, upside





Let’s hope he gets more minutes than Collins. I think after training camp is done will be a better time to assess his level of skill and readiness to contribute. We’re still 3 months away from that point. I think Fab is going to contribute this coming season and surprise a lot of doubters. Go Cs…
Like or Dislike:
2
3
you haven’t watched Collins play..otherwise you wouldn’t be hating on him every chance you get. Even negative Paul thinks he is a good pickup.
Like or Dislike:
1
1
3 & 1 does not impress me. GS had better stats and if Fab was to get the minutes he would too. Yes, I’ve watched JC and yes he can defend. But, I want more from my center than just being able to defend. What happens when it’s time to get a rebound? What happens when he needs to score? 3 & 1 isn’t good or even close to respectable for a 7-footer, so that’s why I am not a fan. I have consistently said I’d rather have MP on the team than JC. And paul is entitled to his opinion, just as I am and just as you are, too. Go Cs…sign MP and cut JC!
Like or Dislike:
1
2
Isn’t the D-League where players go to develop? Fab will get his minutes if he can prove he deserves them. You can’t risk losing games trying to develop rookies when there is a D-league. Why have a D-league?
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Considering how good we are going to be why waste him in the D-League? Why not let’s wait until training camp and see how his progress is and in the pre-season games and then make a decision? We have plenty of games to let him get minutes early in the season with the players that can help him succeed. Playing with weaker players in the D-League is good if he’s not getting any time, but we are so deep I hope we play the youngsters, as opposed to years past, and let them develop so they can be of value come the playoffs. Go Cs…
Like or Dislike:
2
1
I think the Celtics will look to Pierce and KG and say we have to do everything we can to win right now. I hope Fab can be a part of that like Baby was in 2008. To be fair I think most people would see Baby as much further along than Fab in his rookie year. If the team did not have title hopes developing players with on the job training would be easier. Baby averaged about 14 minutes his rookie year, but by the end of season I recall his minutes were closer to 20 minutes. How many minutes would you give Fab? If he falters in the beginning do take the pain and keep playing him in hopes he develops?
Like or Dislike:
0
1
I would give Fab up to 10 mins per game, but only if he shows progress at camp and in the pre-season games. KG should be limited to 30 mins (until the spring) and then CW should spell him or Fab with them sharing the 18 mins left for that position. We know what JC can do so I hope Doc allows Fab time early in the season instead of our playing PP, KG and RR 40+ mins per night. If Fab falters after getting some meaningful time I would then consider sending him to Maine. Camp and the pre-season games should be the barometer of how much he is used. Go Cs…
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Sounds good.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I always root for youth over ‘aged’ vets whose upside is past and whose skills are already maxed out. JC can obviously defend, but I hope Doc changes his don’t play the youngsters policy, as they can help the team if given a proper opportunity. I really hope Joseph gets that chance, as I believe his upside is way higher than JG’s. Wish camp was tomorrow. Go Cs…
Like or Dislike:
0
1
Good article. I think he’s ahead of Christmas in the roster countdown because he is a big. With that being said, Fab’s offensive game is just awful. In the summer league he took some terrible shots. He doesn’t seem to understand the game very well and I think he will foul at an unreal rate in the NBA because he is so slow laterally.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I am not saying Collins is a stopper…but I have never liked seeing him coming into a game against the Celtics.
Like or Dislike:
1
1
Good article, you really made a FAIR assessment of Fab Melo. Noted his strengths, weaknesses, possible remedies of weaknesses & work ethic. I agree, Fab will likely be the 15th man & develop in the D-League & like you I agree he can & will put in the work to be a contributor soon.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I prefer to think of Melo like a draft and stash pick. Just pretend that we drafted a young Brazilian center who won’t be coming over for a year or two. But rather than developing in some random Spanish league, he’s practicing with and coached by NBA people.
Like or Dislike:
1
0
I think you ranked Fab a bit too low. His length and athleticism certainly should put him above Jason Collins at the least.
Like or Dislike:
0
0